Northern Illinois Coal Company became a subsidiary of the Peabody Coal Company in 1955 Mr. Kelce was the president of the Peobody coal company and a sales agent for Sinclair. His brothers and he ran many coal operations.
The idea of developing a recreational club came about rather quickly. Earlier that spring, following a meeting of the Claypool Drainage District, William Weimer, an engineer and land surveyor for the coal company, mentioned to Thomas Berta that the company had completed its strip mining in that area and was interested in selling off the 1,485 acres. The Northern Illinois Coal Co. had operated a strip mining operation in that area for about 30 years
Weimer, Enrietta said, questioned if there was a civic or not-for-profit group in the village that might be interested in the land. In turn, Berta approached the civic club which declared its interest in obtaining the site.
It was the spring of 1958 when a group of local businessmen traveled to the Woodruff Hotel in Joliet to meet with a land agent from the Northern Illinois Coal Co. for the purpose of negotiating a land deal.
The land agent, having arrived by train from southern Illinois, hashed out the purchase price and contract terms with members of the Coal City Civic Club-George Enrietta, John Ross, Bob Trotter, John Winterbottom, Tom Bretto, Don Koerner and BJ Ulivi. The original board members were:
Tom Berta
John Born
Tom Bretto
George Enrietta
John Ross
Bob Trotter
"After the terms were agreed on, we walked across the street to the Union National Bank to have the contract prepared," Enrietta said. Before returning to Coal City, the men signed the contract and paid the agent $30,000 from funds borrowed from the bank.
The balance of the $198,000 sale price was to be paid annually from the purchase of memberships to the new Coal City Area Club.
Not long after the contract was signed, the founding members of the club set out to prepare the land by clearing brush and back filling ditches that had been used to carry the water pumped out from the pits. Quinn Ulivi, a worker at Illinois Clay Products, which was located north of the club property, was granted permission to use some of the company's heavy equipment on the weekends to clear the land. Tom Bretto developed the beach and beach house and interviewed and hired the 1st lifeguard, Hester Hirsch from Wilmington.
Articles in the local Coal City Courant started appearing in the newspaper about the land acquisition and membership was open to only those in the Coal City High School District. The first 500 members would be admitted as “charter members” for the price of $20.00 and would be exempt from paying the annual dues of $15.00.
The operators donated their time, so "the only cost to the club was for the gas and oil," Enrietta said.
New trees planted in the club were provided by a tree nursery located on Carbon Hill Road. The owner had agreed to donate the trees as long as the club dug them up, back filled the holes and leveled the ground.
With the preparation of the site complete, the next step was to bring in electricity, which was accomplished through donated time and materials.
The beach was one of the first areas to be developed and over time, then camping areas began to take shape.
Initial memberships were available only to Coal City residents. "We put it in the paper, but there were locals who were hesitant, they didn't think (the club) would fly," Enrietta said. Unable to support the club on local memberships alone, the board opened the area up for non-local residents to join.